Skip to content

[Totalize pass] mishandling of partial functions calls inside partial functions #177

@DCupello1

Description

@DCupello1

The following spec:

def $inv_isize(nat) : Inn hint(partial)
def $inv_jsize(nat) : Jnn hint(partial)

def $inv_isize(32) = I32
def $inv_isize(64) = I64
def $inv_jsize(8)  = I8
def $inv_jsize(16) = I16
def $inv_jsize(n)  = $inv_isize(n)

gets parsed and transformed into:

def $inv_jsize(nat : nat) : Jnn?
  def $inv_jsize(8) = ?(I8_Jnn)
  def $inv_jsize(16) = ?(I16_Jnn)
  def $inv_jsize{n : n}(n) = ?((!($inv_isize(n)) : Inn <: Jnn))
  def $inv_jsize{x0 : nat}(x0) = ?()

Which has two problems (say we input 3):

  • the ?(!($inv_isize(3)) : Inn <: Jnn) would then be ?(!(None)) which unsure what would be the semantics of this
  • It has the additional case def $inv_jsize{x0 : nat}(x0) = ?(), which specifically in Rocq it does not allow redundant clauses

This is an issue with the totalize pass since it applies the TheE to any partial function which doesn't particularly make sense here.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions